top of page
Search

Storm in Coffee Cup: By Salman Khan. Uncovering the Mysteries of Fluctuating Coffee Bean Prices: A Systematic Root Cause Analysis

  • Salman Khan
  • Jan 13
  • 9 min read

The current surge in coffee bean prices has sparked debates on a global level, and South Africa is no exception. Engaging with discussions across various coffee community forums inspired me to delve deeper into this issue and investigate the factors causing these rapid price increases. This surge poses significant implications for the South African coffee industry, particularly affecting consumers since we heavily rely on imported coffee beans due to our limited local cultivation capabilities.

 Coffee is more than just a beverage; it's a lifeline for millions globally. Yet, the fluctuations in coffee bean prices have become a pressing concern for consumers and producers. Understanding the root causes of these price changes illuminates the sustainability of the industry.


Over the past decade, coffee prices have shifted dramatically. From 2016 to 2021, the price of Arabica coffee beans dropped by nearly 50%, only to experience volatility again in 2022 with an increase of approximately 25%. These price trends raise questions about long-term sustainability for both consumers and farmers. In this post, I will try to investigate anomalies, root causes  and look closely into the factors influencing coffee prices, including climate issues, economic pressures, supply chain disruptions, and changing consumer preferences.


Understanding Coffee Prices


The recent surge in global coffee bean prices reflects a complex interplay of various factors. From climate change and agricultural health to supply chain challenges and shifting consumer trends, each element significantly influences the market.

For coffee drinkers and businesses, understanding these dynamics can shed light on rising costs. Knowledge of the economic factors at play encourages more conscious purchasing. This can support sustainable practices and fair trade.


Though the future may seem uncertain, awareness of these factors empowers consumers to navigate the coffee landscape with greater understanding. Appreciating the intricate relationship between the love for coffee and its economic realities can enhance the overall experience of enjoying your daily cup.


This evolving narrative reveals the delicate balance in the global coffee trade, reminding us that our daily rituals are intertwined with the challenges of nature and economics.


Global Demand and Supply Dynamics


One major factor driving prices is the balance of demand and supply. Global coffee consumption has been steadily rising, particularly in emerging markets. For example, Starbucks reported that their Chinese sales doubled in the past five years, indicating a booming coffee culture in the region.


On the supply side, coffee-growing regions face significant challenges. Adverse weather conditions, such as droughts and excessive rainfall, have impacted major producers like Brazil, where coffee production fell by 30% in 2021 due to such events. This mismatch between demand and supply directly influences coffee bean prices, resulting in volatility that affects everyone in the chain.


Climate Change Effects


Climate change poses critical challenges to agriculture—specifically coffee production. Rising temperatures and changing precipitation patterns lead to unpredictable coffee crop yields. A study found that up to 50% of the world's coffee-growing regions could become unsuitable by 2050 due to climate impacts, forcing farmers to adapt constantly.

These adaptations often require new investments. Farmers may need to switch to more resilient coffee varieties or alter their farming practices. Unfortunately, these changes usually come with higher costs, which are often passed down to consumers in the form of higher prices.


The Impact of Climate Change


Climate change is a major factor impacting coffee production. Coffee plants thrive under specific conditions, and they are sensitive to changes in temperature, rainfall, and humidity. Recently, key coffee-producing areas like Brazil and Colombia have faced severe droughts and heavy rainfall.


For example, Brazil experienced a 20% decline in coffee production in 2021 due to drought, a statistic that illustrates the direct effect of climate challenges on supply. As the supply diminishes while demand stays steady, prices inevitably climb.


Health of Coffee Farms


The overall health of coffee farms critically influences prices. Many farmers are battling issues like coffee leaf rust, a disease that can devastate crops. This is compounded by increasing fungal diseases linked to climate change.


For instance, in Central America, the coffee leaf rust epidemic caused a 40% drop in production, forcing many farmers out of business. When yields decline from pests or diseases, it tightens the coffee supply. This, combined with steady demand, drives prices upward.


Economic Factors


Economic elements significantly influence coffee prices. For example, the World Bank reported that inflation rates in coffee-exporting countries surged by 7% in 2021, leading to increased operational costs for farmers. As prices for fertilizers, labor, and transportation rise, these costs are inevitably passed on to consumers.

Additionally, trade policies also play a crucial role. For instance, in 2020, new tariffs on coffee imports in several countries disrupted established supply chains and contributed to price increases for consumers.

 

Analyzing the historical pattern of the coffee beans price index from the above chart reveals that, over the past 50 years, coffee prices have surged by more than 700%, a trend unmatched by any other FMCG commodity.


The above chart show the last year head and shoulder graph of coffee beans rise on rise and currently siting on USD 3.24 per Lbs and no sight of retrogressing to early 2024 prices.


Coffee increased 4.44 USd/Lbs or 1.38% since the beginning of 2025, according to trading on a contract for difference (CFD) that tracks the benchmark market for this commodity. Coffee is expected to trade at 329.91 USd/Lbs by the end of this quarter, according to Trading Economics global macro models and analysts expectations. Looking forward, we estimate it to trade at 358.63 in 12 months’ time. Some commodity brokers on the NYSE are predicting that the current trend will persist and surpass USD 3.75 per pound. With coffee prices reaching unprecedented levels, this is certainly a nerve-wracking period for coffee importers and café owners alike, but there is silver lining to it as there are good news of rains in Brazil and Columbia to give some relief to the coffee bean farmers. 

The above grid indicates that behind Cocoa price surge of 147% last near coffee beans follow with the second highest rise of 76.54% these trends does give uncertainty and nervous feeling to many in coffee industry.

 

Global Economic Factors


Wider economic factors also play a crucial role in coffee pricing. Factors like inflation rates, currency changes, and geopolitical tensions can significantly affect coffee prices.

In countries that export coffee, rising inflation can lead to increased production costs. For example, in Brazil, inflation hit 8.5% in 2021, causing production expenses to rise. These costs typically transfer to consumers and contribute to higher prices in the global market. Additionally, when local currencies depreciate against the dollar, the costs for exporting coffee beans swell, further pushing prices higher.

 

Shifting Consumer Preferences


Recent shifts in consumer behavior are also affecting coffee prices. More people are willing to invest in specialty coffees and premium products, driving demand for quality over quantity.


For instance, statistics show that specialty coffee sales have increased by 15% over the past three years, driven by consumers willing to pay more for artisanal brews. This creates an upward pressure on prices, especially as sustainable farming practices often come with higher costs.


The Role of Speculation


The coffee market experiences speculation, just like many global commodities. Traders often predict future production levels and price trends, which can lead to increased volatility.


For example, when predictions indicate that a bad harvest is on the horizon, traders may raise prices in anticipation. This can create a self-fulfilling cycle, where speculative actions lead to inflated prices that ultimately affect consumers.


Market Speculation


Speculation in the commodities market can lead to significant price shifts. Coffee is seen as a safe investment, and traders react quickly to market rumors. For instance, when negative forecasts regarding supply occur, investors may buy up large quantities, driving prices up. Conversely, if there is optimistic news, they may sell off, leading to price drops that do not always align with actual market conditions.


These fluctuations can create confusion. Many consumers may find themselves paying more, even when there hasn't been a corresponding increase in production costs.


Sustainable Practices and Their Costs


The demand for sustainable coffee is rising, putting pressure on farmers to adopt ethical farming practices. Employing organic farming techniques and eco-friendly pest control often requires an upfront investment. For example, transitioning a farm to fully organic can cost farmers up to 30% more at the start.


Though these methods benefit the environment and potentially improve coffee quality, they also lead to higher prices as farmers work to recover their initial costs. However, the long-term advantages—like resilience against climate impacts—may help stabilize prices over time.


The Coffee Supply Chain


The complicated supply chain from farm to consumer can amplify price fluctuations. Each participant in this chain takes a margin, and inefficiencies can lead to price increases that don’t match actual production costs. Research suggests that streamlining the supply chain by reducing the number of intermediaries could lower prices, benefitting both producers and consumers.


Investing in technologies that offer direct connections between growers and consumers can lead to more stable pricing. For instance, platforms like direct-trade coffee companies have shown success in providing transparency and fair prices to farmers.


Supply Chain Challenges


The COVID-19 pandemic significantly disrupted supply chains, impacting the coffee industry as well. Logistical challenges from the pandemic, including shipping delays and rising freight costs, have caused prices to increase.


Labor shortages in coffee-producing countries have also added to the problem. According to industry reports, labor shortages have decreased production by around 25% in some regions. Fewer workers mean less coffee is produced, leading to higher prices for consumers.


Addressing Farmer Concerns


While rising coffee prices affect consumers, farmers face the greatest challenges. Many coffee-producing regions struggle with low prices that often lead to poverty. For example, in Honduras, coffee farmers reported that they receive only about 30% of the retail price of coffee sold abroad.


Advocacies for fair trade practices and supporting farmer cooperatives can create a more equitable system. Greater transparency in pricing helps consumers understand the factors that affect coffee costs and allows them to support ethical practices.


How Will South Africa's Coffee Industry and Consumers Adapt to Rising Coffee Bean Prices?


The coffee culture in South Africa has always been bustling, filled with vibrant cafés and local roasters. However, the industry now faces a pressing challenge: rising coffee bean prices. Global events and changing weather patterns are affecting supply chains and crop yields, prompting both industry stakeholders and consumers to rethink their approaches. In this article, we will explore the factors causing these price hikes, their implications for South Africa's coffee sector, and how consumers may adjust their habits accordingly.


The Current State of South Africa’s Coffee Industry


The South African coffee industry combines local roasters, specialty cafés, and larger chains. Coffee production has grown, particularly in regions such as KwaZulu-Natal and Mpumalanga, but it still relies heavily on imports. Currently, approximately 95% of the coffee consumed in South Africa is imported.


Small and medium-sized coffee businesses are under significant pressure due to the rising costs. For many, maintaining profitability without transferring these costs to consumers may be difficult, leading to potential changes in pricing strategies. Some establishments may need to close their doors, while others might focus on differentiating their offerings to stay competitive.


Consumer Impact: Adjusting Purchasing Habits


With increasing prices, consumers may alter their purchasing behaviors. Many coffee lovers may switch to more affordable options or reduce their consumption frequency. A recent study showed that 54% of casual coffee drinkers have considered cutting back on daily coffee habits in light of rising prices.


For enthusiasts, there may still be a willingness to pay for premium products, but most consumers are becoming more price-conscious. As a result, many people may choose to brew coffee at home rather than visiting cafés frequently. This shift may lead to a surge in sales for affordable coffee-making equipment and budget-friendly beans.


The Future of South Africa’s Coffee Scene


As we look to the future, the landscape of South Africa's coffee scene may undergo significant changes. Businesses and consumers alike will need to adapt to this new reality. We might witness a rise in environmentally friendly options and a greater focus on coffee quality.


Building innovative partnerships among local producers and roasters can lead to a more self-sufficient coffee industry. In doing so, consumers can enjoy affordable yet high-quality coffee that supports local economies.


The Path Ahead


The increasing prices of coffee beans present challenges for South Africa's coffee industry while simultaneously encouraging consumers to adapt. As industry players seek strategies to manage rising costs, consumers may lean toward choices that prioritize sustainability and quality.


This transformative period requires collaboration. Both sides must adjust to market shifts while embracing changing consumer preferences. Whether through innovative business strategies, sustainability initiatives, or shifts in consumer habits, the future is bright for South Africa's coffee culture, which is poised to thrive despite the obstacles ahead.

Freshly harvested coffee beans ready for sale.

 

Closing Thoughts


The complexities behind rising coffee bean prices include global market dynamics, climate change, economic pressures, speculation, and intricacies within the coffee supply chain. While rising prices may reflect increased demand and supply challenges, sustainability remains a critical concern.


As consumers lean towards ethically produced coffee, it is essential to balance the economic viability for farmers with sustainable practices necessary for the coffee industry's future. By staying informed about these factors, we can work together to find solutions that stabilize prices and support farmers.


Each sip of our beloved brew carries a story shaped by these various elements, reminding us of our connection to the global coffee community.


There are some good news as the South Africa is rebound to the pre-Covid 19 numbers and over 200 local and international exhibitions and events are planned for 2025 and not discounting the massive pour of international arrivals during G20 summit in November in South Africa will provide food and drink retailers some break.


Doesn’t matter how the cookie crumble but as the Wiseman said once “A good cup of coffee must be followed by another good cup of coffee”.

 



Salman Khan is a Barista judge, social entrepreneur, food and drink anthropologist, researcher and culinary educator.


To access 2024 coffee consumer survey report in South Africa please send an email to by a copy of it.


WhatsApp 082 691 6048



 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page